Background Overlay

Focus on Funds
Newsletter

Foreign Partner’s Gain on Sale of U.S. Partnership Interest is not Effectively Connected Income

The U.S. Tax Court recently held that a foreign partner's gain on the sale of its interest in a U.S. partnership was not effectively connected income subject to U.S. tax. In reaching its conclusion in Grecian Magnesite Mining v. Commissioner, the court rejected a 1991 IRS Revenue Ruling.

 

The case is favorable for foreign investors in U.S. funds and other U.S. businesses classified as partnerships.

International Tax Primer

U.S. citizens and resident aliens are generally subject to U.S. tax on their worldwide income. Non-U.S. persons, including non-resident aliens and foreign corporations, are generally subject to U.S. tax on:

1. Effectively connected income (ECI) — income that’s “effectively connected” with a U.S. trade or business in which the taxpayer is engaged, and

2. U.S.-source Fixed or Determinable Annual or Periodical income (FDAP income), such as dividends, certain interest, rent, royalties, and compensation.

ECI is taxed on a net basis at graduated rates. FDAP income is generally taxed on a gross basis at a flat 30% rate (unless a lower rate applies pursuant to a tax treaty). Non-U.S. taxpayers are exempt from tax on capital gains from the sale of U.S. securities and other capital assets, unless such gains are ECI. Foreign owners of U.S. real property interests are also deemed to be engaged in the U.S. trade or business of owning real estate if they own U.S. real property directly or through an entity.

In Revenue Ruling 91-32, the IRS adopted the position that non-U.S. persons owning an interest in a partnership engaged in a U.S. trade or business are subject to tax when they sell their partnership interest. The IRS reached this conclusion based on the “aggregate theory”, which views a partnership as an aggregation of its partners rather than as a discrete legal entity. Therefore, a partner’s sale of its partnership interest is treated as a disposition of its interest in the partnership’s assets.

Case Background

Grecian Magnesite Mining (GMM), a Greek mining corporation, owned a minority interest in Premier Chemicals, a Delaware LLC classified as a partnership for tax purposes and engaged in mining activities in the U.S. Other than its interest in Premier, GMM had no U.S. offices, employees, or business operations.

In 2008, Premier agreed to redeem GMM’s interest in exchange for two cash payments, resulting in a gain to GMM of approximately $6.2 million. Although GMM had filed U.S. tax returns reporting its distributive share of Premier’s income, gain, loss, and deductions and credits, it did not report the gain from the redemption of its ownership interest.

On audit, the IRS determined that GMM should have recognized the entire amount as U.S.-source capital gain. GMM conceded that $2.2 million of the gain was attributable to U.S. real property interests and, therefore, was taxable. GMM disputed the taxability of the remaining $4 million.

Aggregate Theory and Office Rule

To decide the case, the tax court considered and rejected two IRS arguments.

First, the IRS urged the court to adopt the “aggregate theory”, which would treat GMM’s sale of its LLC interest as a sale of its interest in the LLC’s assets. In this instance, because Premier used those assets in its U.S. trade or business, the gain would be considered ECI.

In disagreeing with this theory, the court observed that the tax code generally follows the “entity theory” which treats the sale of a partnership interest as the sale of a single, indivisible capital asset. The existence of exceptions to the entity theory in the Internal Revenue Code for U.S. real property interests and certain “hot assets,” such as appreciated inventory and unrealized receivables, prove this rule. If Congress had intended the aggregate theory to apply to all sales of partnership interests, those exceptions would have been superfluous.

Having determined GMM’s gain was from the sale of its partnership interest rather than from the partnership’s underlying assets, the tax court held it was foreign-source income and not ECI. Generally, gain from the sale of personal property is sourced based on the residency of the seller.

The IRS countered that the gain should be treated as U.S. source ECI under the “U.S. office rule.” Under such rule, if a non-U.S. taxpayer maintains an office or other fixed place of business in the U.S., income from the sale of personal property attributable to that fixed place of business is sourced in the U.S. While the court agreed that Premier’s U.S. office was deemed to be GMM’s fixed place of business by virtue of its LLC interest, it rejected the argument that GMM’s gain was attributable to that office. Such an argument would require that the office was a “material factor” in the production of the gain and the office carried out the activities producing the gain in the ordinary course of business.

The IRS argued that the office was a material factor as it was material to the deemed sale of GMM's share of the LLC’s assets. Alternatively, the IRS said it was material to the increased value of Premier that GMM realized in the redemption. The first argument failed because the court had already held that GMM sold its LLC interest and not its share of the LLC’s assets. The court also rejected the second argument, explaining that it “conflates the ongoing value of a business operation with gain from the sale of an interest in that business.” In addition, the redemption was a “one-time, extraordinary event”, not a purchase in the ordinary course of business.

What’s Next?

The tax court’s decision is a victory for foreign investors in U.S. partnerships, but the implications of the decision are not yet clear. The IRS may appeal the decision, issue a non-acquiescence and continue to follow Rev. Rul. 91-32, or it may develop new theories for taxation of such gains. It is also possible that the IRS and Treasury Department will issue regulations adopting the reasoning of Rev. Rul. 91-32, or that Congress will pass legislation codifying the ruling.

In the meantime, foreign investors who have already paid U.S. tax on gains from the disposition of partnership interests should consider filing protective refund claims before the statute of limitations expires.

If you feel this tax court decision has relevance to your operations, please contact your Untracht Early representative.

Grecian Magnesite Mining v. Commissioner, 149 T.C. No. 3 (2017)

PLEASE READ THESE TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF USE CAREFULLY. THIS IS A LEGAL CONTRACT.

Acceptance of Terms of Use

The Untracht Early LLC (UE) client portal is offered to you on the condition of your acceptance of the terms, conditions and notices contained herein. By using the portal you agree to these terms and conditions. If you are not a client or authorized employee of UE, any use by you of the portal is prohibited.

Description of Service

The portal provides UE’s clients with access to information displayed on the portal for inquiries and deliveries of documents and communications for their account only. The information, documents and communications on the portal are provided as a convenient resource to clients, their attorneys, agents and other designated representatives (collectively, “Agents”) and may be used for informational purposes only for their account. To the extent you wish to authorize any Agents to access your account, you must sign and return the form of Authorization set forth below.

User Password and Security

Using the portal and its related services requires the use of a password and a user name. The confidentiality of your password and account is your responsibility. Any activities that occur under your account either by you or your Agents are your responsibility. You agree to notify us immediately of any unauthorized use of your account or any other breach of security. It is prohibited to use anyone else’s account without the express permission of that account holder.

Accuracy of Content and Liability Disclaimer

UE will strive to use reasonable efforts to include accurate and updated information on the portal; HOWEVER, YOU UNDERSTAND AND AGREE THAT UE IS UNDER NO OBLIGATION TO DO SO AND NEITHER UE NOR ITS SUPPLIERS, AGENTS OR REPRESENTATIVES MAKE ANY REPRESENTATION OR WARRANTY ABOUT THE SUSTAINABILITY, RELIABILITY, AVAILABILITY, TIMELINESS, AND ACCURACY OF THE INFORMATION, SOFTWARE, DOCUMENTS AND COMMUNICATIONS CONTAINED ON THE PORTAL FOR ANY PURPOSE TO THE MAXIMUM EXTENT PERMITTED BY APPLICABLE LAW. ALL SUCH INFORMATION, SOFTWARE, DOCUMENTS AND COMMUNICATIONS ARE PROVIDED “AS IS” WITHOUT WARRANTY OR CONDITION OF ANY KIND. UE, AND ITS SUPPLIERS, AGENTS AND REPRESENTATIVES HEREBY DISCLAIM ALL WARRANTIES AND CONDITIONS WITH REGARD TO SUCH INFORMATION, SOFTWARE, DOCUMENTS AND COMMUNICATIONS, INCLUDING WITHOUT LIMITATION, ALL IMPLIED WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS OF MERCHANTABILITY, FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE, TITLE AND NON-INFRINGEMENT.

TO THE MAXIMUM EXTENT PERMITTED BY APPLICABLE LAW, IN NO EVENT SHALL UE, OR ITS SUPPLIERS, AGENTS OR REPRESENTATIVES BE LIABILE FOR ANY DIRECT, INDIRECT, PUNITIVE, INCIDENTAL, SPECIAL OR CONSEQUENTIAL DAMAGES OR ANY OTHER DAMAGES WHATSOEVER, INCLUDING WITHOUT LIMITATION, DAMAGES FOR LOSS OF USE, DATA OR PROFITS, ARISING OUT OF OR IN ANY WAY CONNECTED WITH YOUR OR YOUR AGENTS’ USE OR THE PERFORMANCE OF THE PORTAL, WITH THE DELAY OR INABILITY TO USE THE PORTAL OR RELATED SERVICES, WHETHER BASED IN CONTRACT, TORT, NEGLIGENCE, STRICT LIABILITY OR OTHERWISE, EVEN IF UE OR ITS SUPPLIERS, AGENTS AND REPRESENTATIVES HAVE BEEN ADVISED OF THE POSSIBILITY OF DAMAGES. CERTAIN STATES DO NOT PERMIT TYPES OF THESE LIMITATIONS, SO THE ABOVE LIMITATIONS MAY NOT APPLY TO YOU. IF YOU ARE DISSATISFIED WITH ANY PORTION OF THE PORTAL INFORMATION, DOCUMENTS OR COMMUNICATIONS ON THE PORTAL, OR WITH ANY OF THESE TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF USE, YOUR SOLE AND EXCLUSIVE REMEDY IS TO CEASE USING THE PORTAL AND THE INFORMATION, DOCUMENTS OR COMMUNICATIONS YOU OBTAINED FROM THE PORTAL.

Icons, Logos and Other Proprietary Material

The trademarks, logos, and service marks (collectively the “Trademarks”) displayed on the portal are registered and common law trademarks of this firm. Nothing contained on the portal should be construed as granting, by implication, or otherwise, any license or right to use any of the Trademarks displayed on the portal without the written permission of this firm. Your use of any of the Trademarks displayed on the portal or displayed on any content on the portal is strictly prohibited. You should assume that everything you see or read on the portal is copyrighted and is a trade secret and may not be used except as provided in these terms and conditions of use or in the text on the portal without the written permission of this firm or its suppliers.

Changes to Terms and Conditions of Use

UE may at any time modify the terms, conditions and notices under which the portal is offered by updating this posting. You are bound to any such modifications and should therefore periodically visit this page to review the then-current terms and conditions to which you are bound.

Confidentiality, Information Protection, and Protection Data

Notwithstanding any existing legal or contractual obligations regarding confidentiality between you and UE, you undertake to treat all knowledge relating to business secrets, which come into your possession, as confidential. You shall assure that any protected data, which comes into your possession through the use of the portal, is not transmitted to any unauthorized person. In partial consideration of the opportunity to access the resources of the portal concerning your account, you agree to maintain the strict confidentiality of access of the portal and its data to you and your authorized Agents and to indemnify and hold harmless UE and its officers, shareholders and employees and their heirs, successors and assigns from and against any and all claims, actions, demands, losses, damages, judgments, costs and expenses, including without limitation, reasonable attorneys’ fees and liabilities of every kind which may arise from your or your employees’ or agents’ use of the portal or because of violation of these terms and conditions of use.

No Unlawful or Prohibited Use

You are prohibited from using the portal to damage, disable, or overburden UE’s servers or network or impair the portal or interfere with any other party’s use of the portal. Hacking, password mining or any other means to gain unauthorized access to the portal, portal accounts, computers or network is prohibited. Posting or transmitting any unlawful, threatening, libelous, defamatory, obscene, scandalous, inflammatory, pornographic, or profane material or any material that could constitute or encourage conduct that would be considered a criminal offense, give rise to a civil liability, or otherwise violate any law is also prohibited. UE will fully cooperate with any law enforcement authorities or court order requesting or directing this firm to disclose the identity of anyone posting any such information and materials. This firm is an equal opportunity employer and values the diversity of its people.

RELEASE AND INDEMNITY. IN AGREEING TO USE, AND BY USING, THE UNTRACHT EARLY PORTAL, YOU ALSO AGREE TO, AND HEREBY DO, RELEASE AND DISCHARGE UNTRACHT EARLY FROM ANY AND ALL CLAIMS OF EVERY NATURE AND DESCRIPTION ARISING OUT OF OR RELATING TO THE POSTING OF INFORMATION ON THE PORTAL, YOUR OR YOUR AGENTS’ USE OF THE PORTAL, AND/OR ANY BREACH OF SECURITY INVOLVING THE PORTAL. YOU HEREBY AGREE TO INDEMNIFY AND DEFEND UNTRACHT EARLY, ITS AGENTS, REPRESENTATIVES AND EMPLOYEES AGAINST ANY CLAIMS, DEMANDS, LAWSUITS AND OTHER PROCEEDINGS MADE ABOUT YOU, MADE BY THOSE IN PRIVITY WITH YOU OR MADE BY THOSE ACTING IN CONCERT WITH YOU, IN ANY WAY, WITH REFERENCE TO YOU OR YOUR INFORMATION OR BY ANY THIRD PARTIES ON YOUR BEHALF (INCLUDING AGENTS) RELATING IN ANY WAY TO THE UNTRACHT EARLY PORTAL.